Five generations on Smith's Plantation, Beaufort, South Carolina

The African Americans: Many Rivers to Cross – Episode Two – Tie Deep South to Up South

this is the second of six posts dedicated to providing a genealogical context for the PBS series, The African Americans: Many Rivers to Cross by Henry Louis Gates, Jr. click here to read all the posts i’ve written about the series. (Photo: Five generations on Smith’s Plantation, Beaufort, South Carolina, Library of Congress)

episode two: the age of slavery

episode two provided an in depth look at the complexities and evolution of slavery in the United States. what resonated for me was the following collection of quotes from host Henry Louis Gates, Jr.

“Slaves in the upper south became commodities for the demand in the deep south and were sold off in droves…more than a million African Americans were ‘carried’ into the Deep South to fuel King Cotton. 2.5 times the number that were brought to the United States from Africa.” – Henry Louis Gates, Jr.

as mentioned in episode two, the following lead to the boom in cotton production in the United States:

booming textile industry in England

+ decline in value and viability of tobacco and other crops in the United States

+ creation of the cotton gin (opportunity for a new cash crop and business)


= the boom of king cotton in the united states

while many African American researchers are aware of and talk about how their ancestors were sold off to other slaveholders while in the deep south, i rarely hear conversations about the more than one million that were taken from the upper south to the deep south. that’s A LOT of people.

how many of your formerly enslaved ancestors were part of that one million who were migrated from 1790-1860?

Enslaved Ancestor Birth States

| Infographics

after some analysis, i saw that more of my formerly enslaved ancestors were born in Virginia and Tennessee, which are considered part of the upper south. it’s easy to think that these particular ancestors were caught up in that one million people who were sold or carried off.

what do you mean ‘carried off’?

episode two implied this, but didn’t specifically say it. it mentioned the forced removal of Native Americans from lands they worked and inhabited, but what it failed to mention was the slaveholders in the upper south who came to acquire those lands once the Native American people were removed. this was done at times through land patents issued by the US government. the forced removal and slaveholder migration (and by virtue enslaved people migration) happened largely because the lands in the upper south were in bad shape and nowhere near as fertile as those in the new deep south.

is it hard to track someone who was ‘carried off?’

no, not at all! as mentioned previously, this can require a combination of oral history, county, and federal documents.

my 4x great grandmother was named Margaret Russell; i’m a direct female descendant of her. through oral history and genealogy research, Margaret was born a slave and died one. i obtained information about her from her daughter, Caroline Russell Carson, who lived to see freedom, later married a man who was part of the US Colored Troops, and collected her deceased husband’s pension. caroline stated that she was told she was born in Baltimore, Maryland.

Claiborne County MS Probate Record Book K, Page 397
Claiborne County MS Probate Record Book K, Page 397. John, value $300; Caroline, value $150.

how can we determine that Margaret was part of the one million when she was born and died a slave?

it’s simpler than you think once you establish the trail of slaveownership.

trace the genealogy of the slaveholder, find your ancestors.

Caroline mentioned that she was owned by Lucinda Grace and that when she could first remember, she was living in Port Gibson, Claiborne, Mississippi and Yazoo, Mississippi. visiting that Claiborne County courthouse, our research team was able to discover that Lucinda was bequeathed Caroline, her sister Susan (my 3x great grandmother), and their father John (my 4x great grandfather) in October 1844 upon the death of her husband William Bush. (Claiborne County, MS Probate Court (Labeled Orphan’s Court) Book K, Page 397, October 25, 1844: Inventory of the Estate of William D. Bush.)

from there, we found a transaction where William Bush purchased a 540 acre plantation and not only Caroline and Susan, but their father John AND their mother Margaret in January 1838 from Robert Frazier Moore and Celeste Moore and Joseph and Elizabeth Nichols (Claiborne County, MS Book R, Pages 219-222). based upon the probate and deed records, we discovered that Margaret was born about 1816. but where was she born? was it in the upper or deep south? could we assume it was Maryland since her daughter Caroline was told that?

Clora Evans Atlas (1858-1928). Granddaughter or Margaret Russell.
Clora Evans Atlas (1858-1928). Granddaughter of Margaret Russell. 

Celeste Moore was the daughter of Joseph and Elizabeth Nichols. a Google and Ancestry.Com search states that Celeste and family were from…*drumroll*…Maryland. OK, we could just stop here, right? nope.

the natural thing to do would be to see if we could find a transaction where the Moores and Nichols’ purchased Caroline, Susan, John, and Margaret. we did that, but we only found where the Moores and Nichols’ bought the 540 plantation in January 1837 but NO slaves were part of the transaction. this could definitely indicate that Caroline and company were brought or carried from Maryland during the 1790-1860 time period noted in episode two.

wait. what happened to Margaret? she wasn’t bequeathed with her husband and children in 1844?

of note is the disappearance of Margaret from the 1844 probate record for William Bush. oral history states that she was sold off and Caroline’s pension file deposition supports this as she said she was raised “motherless.” Caroline would have only been six years old when this happened. it’s likely that Margaret would have been sold at Forks of the Road in Natchez, Adams, Mississippi since it was only 42 miles away from Port Gibson. imagine being sold away from your 6 and 9 year old daughters and being forced to walk almost 14 hours for the “privilege.”

oral history says that Margaret was allegedly the daughter of her owner OR had a child with them. as i often speak about in my presentations, there is a prevalence of European DNA in the average African American genome is between 10-60%. so, while you trace your African American ancestors who were carried, you may need to trace your European ancestors who did the carrying or the selling.

sold or ‘carried away,’ it’s clear that when you get into researching during the time period mentioned during episode two, you have to almost always consider that your ancestors were one in a million.


continue the blogging circle!

other genealogists are contributing their commentary for each episode too. here are links to their commentary on episode two.

Terry Ligon – Timelines Cross Many Rivers

Melvin Collier – The African Americans, Many Rivers to Cross – Episode 2: The Second Middle Passage

George Geder – The Age of Slavery 1780-1860; Pt 2

Angela Walton-Raji – Resistance Among America’s Forgotten Slaves (Many Rivers to Cross Blogging Circle Response to Episode 2)

Vicky Daviss-Mitchell – Steal Away, Steal Away, King Cotton is Coming!

watch episode two

episode two resources

Elizabeth Freeman, aka Mumbet in MARichard Allen and the AME churchGabriel Prosser and the botched slave revoltBrown Fellowship Society CemeterySlave Relic Museum, Walterboro, SCNat Turner Rebellion

1 thought on “The African Americans: Many Rivers to Cross – Episode Two – Tie Deep South to Up South”

  1. I know that my ancestors were often born further east than where they died. They were part of that great migration, either sold south or moved when the master moved. I like the chart.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top